The ... (space and time). common time interval. 2/Consequently, only the B-edition differentiates between metaphysical and transcendental expositions of space and gives their respective definitions. The Transcendental Exposition shows that space must really be as exposited in the Metaphysical Exposition. the concept ‘exposition’. $3 The Transcendental Exposition of the Concept of Space I understand by a transcendental exposition the explana- tion of a concept, as a principle from which the possibility of other a priori synthetic knowledge can be understood. 17. Get this from a library! Kant now begins the “transcendental” exposition of this concept. 6. 1. Kant’s discussions of Space and Time offer five arguments with respect to each intuition, four “metaphysical” and one “transcendental.” In his metaphysical exposition, Kant aims to show that Space is both a priori (rather than empirical) and an intuition (rather than a concept), and he offers two arguments for each aspect of his claim. Here his aim is to show how the concept of space functions in synthetic judgments that are made a priori. Inthetranscendental aesthetic weshall, therefore, first A22 isolate sensibility, bytaking awayfromiteverything whichthe understanding thinks through itsconcepts, sothatnothing maybeleftsaveempirical intuition. The contention that transcendental idealism and transcendental realism differ in their conceptions of the relation between space and intuition, rather than space and the mind, is significant. important concept in Transcendental deduction is that of apperception. 1 This is undoubtedly because of the threat which non-Euclidean geometries pose to it and because of the interest which for this reason philosophies of … § 3: Transcendental Exposition of the Concept of Space; SUPPLEMENT IX; SUPPLEMENT X § 5: Transcendental Exposition of the Concept of Time; SUPPLEMENT XI; Conclusion of the Transcendental Æsthetic; SUPPLEMENT XII § 11 § 12; SUPPLEMENT XIII; SUPPLEMENT XIV; OF THE DEDUCTION OF THE PURE CONCEPTS OF THE UNDERSTANDING Now, Kant thinks that the “exposition” of the concept of this space will show that it has certain distinctive things that “belongs to” it (B38), namely, that its content represents space as possessing certain features. For each space and time, Kant divides his discussion into what he calls a “Metaphysical” and a “Transcendental” Exposition. Shapes and durations, spatial relations and time intervals could, then, be taken as belonging to a general concept of space and to a general concept of I. Transcendental Doctrine of Elements: First Part—TRANSCENDENTAL AESTHETIC § 1. Kant's transcendental exposition of space is that our idea of space is an a priori intuition that encompasses all of our possible sensations. Synthetic and analytic argument 130 I understand by a transcendental exposition the explanation of concept as a principle" from which insight into the possibility of other synthetic a priori cognitions can be gained. D. the Transcendental Exposition of the Concept of Time. These a priori concepts is named “categories”. The transcendental exposition of the concept of space has perhaps received more attention than the metaphysical exposition. Allison (1983), p. 136.All subsequent quotations will follow the usual A/B convention and are from Kant (1998).. 2 ‘Gerd Buchdahl introduced himself to philosophy at the age of fifteen, when, ‘with bated breath’, he read Kant’s arguments about space and time in his father’s so far unopened Insel Verlag edition of the Critique’ (Woolhouse, 1988, p. 1). The central argument of the TE, the so-called ‘argument from geometry’ was originally part of the ME, located between the two pairs of arguments discussed above. The Transcendental Exposition of Space. Introductory : SECTION I. Transcendental exposition Of the concept of space. Transcendental Exposition of the Conception of Space. 34 The Transcendental Exposition of time relies, in a similar fashion, on what Kant refers to as the ‘general theory of motion ... Kant draws the inference that the concept of space is necessarily applicable to objects of our cognition. Space, geometry, and Kant's Transcendental deduction of the categories. Space contains too many parts within itself, so that space is more likely to be intuitions and not concepts. It is highly recommended for the reader to review the Translator’s Appendix II.1 (page 788) for the translator’s Introductory Notes and Comments on the entire Cri- 19If what I say about the nature of an exposition is correct, then the Transcendental Exposition of the Concept of Space (TECS) also rests on analytic knowledge of the given concept of space. Which of these four arguments focuses on our ability to recognize that some things are outside of ourselves and alongside each other? Transcendental exposition of the concept of space. B. the Transcendental Exposition of the Concept of Space. OF SPACE § 2. The transcendental exposition of the concept of time is given in item 3. Conclusions from the foregoing Conceptions. The centrality and importance of this claim about space makes this For statements to this effect, see A6/B10, A10/ B13f., and AA 24:916. The goal of the transcendental deduction is to show ... transcendental exposition is the explanation of concept as a principle The transcendental expositions attempt to show how the metaphysical conclusions might be applied to enrich our understanding. An exposition of the marks of the concept of subjective space not only shows that space is a form of sensibility, but that it is a continuous, actually infinite whole, which precedes its potentially infinite parts. 3 Kant often makes such claims to explanatory uniqueness, for example, in the Transcendental Exposition of the Concept of Space added to the second [“B”] edition (B 41): “Therefore, only our explanation makes the possibility of geometry as an a priori synthetic cognition comprehensible. Drawing on Critical and pre-Critical texts, I … As before Kant means to suggest that a particular feature of the concept of. I understand by a transcendental exposition the explanation of a concept, as a principle from which the possibility of other a priori synthetic knowledge can be understood. For this purpose it is required (1) that such knowledge does really flow … The concept of space is the concept of the object which is given a priori in intuition. Transcendental Aesthetic. OF TIME § 5. Demonstrating these is the ultimate goal of the Deduction of the Categories and the similarly structured Transcendental Exposition of the Concept of Space, respectively. SECTION II. SPACE 67 ingthefirst partofthetranscendental doctrine ofelements, B36 indistinction fromthatpartwhich deals withtheprinciples ofpurethought, andwhich iscalled transcendental logic. But this does not mean that analytic knowledge cannot be extremely useful. Essay. 3. Metaphysical Exposition of this Conception. In Kant’s terminology space is an analytic whole, which gives a key to the ideality of space… This task in turn has two parts. Metaphysical exposition of As before kant means to suggest that a particular School Harvard University; Course Title PHIL 243; Type. a concept', and the exposition is metaphysical 'when it contains that which exhibits the concept as given a priori' (A23/B38). Transcendental Exposition of the Conception of Space. § 4. Thus, where in the B-edition Kant says “let us first expose the concept of space” (B 38), in the A-edition he only says: “let us first consider space” (A 23). A ‘transcendental’ exposition of a concept is an explanation of its role in enabling us to understand the possibility of other synthetic a priori knowledge. § 3. By a transcendental exposition, I mean the explanation of a conception, as a principle, whence can be discerned the possibility of other synthetical à priori cognitions. The last argument is that space is also not a concept as space is infinite, making the process of concept formation impossible. Different kinds of abstraction 124 VI SPACE AND TIME-TRANSCENDENTAL EXPOSITION AND CONCLUSIONS I. Transcendental Exposition of space and time 127 2. Consequently, the original representation of space is an a - priori intuition, not a concept. Most importantly, Kant thinks the exposition of the concept of space shows (1) The corresponding item 3 in the first-edition exposition of the concept of space was replaced by a new section, §3. The programme of the Metaphysical Expositions thus becomes an analysis of the manner in which one's representations of space and time are possible, and a determination Like the exposition of space, there is a metaphysical exposition (B46--48), arguing from first principles that time is an a priori intuition; and a transcendental exposition (B48--B49), which argues that time must be an a priori intuition in order for us to make use of the synthetic a priori concept of succession. • Transcendental exposition of a concept is the explication of a concept that permits insight into the possibility of other synthetic a priori judgments. n the Transcendental Exposition of the Concept of Space, early in the Critique of Pure Reason, Kant aims to establish that space is transcendentally ideal by presenting what has come to be known as ‘the argument from geometry ’. Transcendental Deduction of the Categories and the Paralogisms. Space: Kant’s Metaphysical Exposition Revisited DOI 10.1515/agph-2015-0017 Abstract: I offer here an account of the methodology, historical context, and content of Kant’s so-called “Metaphysical Exposition of the Concept of Space” (MECS). It is not possible to imagine space’s edge. Uploaded By mwakimadavid. This reflects the structure of the first edition. For this aim it is required r) that such cognitions actually flow from the given concept, and 2) thai A. the Metaphysical Exposition of the Concept of Space. [Thomas C Vinci] -- In section 20 in the B edition 'Deduction', Kant states that his purpose is achieved: to show that all intuitions in general are subject to the categories. The transcendental ideality of space and time provides the very possibility of every empirical intuition, and to this effect, space and time are “empirically real”. When Hegel considers space and time, he begins his exposition with a bow to Kant’s treatment, but it is also clear that whatever truth is to be found in the Kantian view, transcendental idealism will not survive, for Hegel is convinced that transcendental idealism is just another name for subjective idealism, and that is anathema. In the transcendental exposition, Kant refers back to his metaphysical exposition in order to show that the sciences would be impossible if space and time were not kinds of pure a priori intuitions.
2020 transcendental exposition of the concept of space